It’s not a sentence, it’s a full stop

Hakamada Iwao is on death row in Japan. Japan’s policy is to execute by hanging in secret. Prisoners are typically given a few hours notice, or none at all. Families are only notified after the execution has happened.

This means Hakamada has spent 43 years not knowing if today would be his last.

Hakamada Iwao has been on death row for 43 years

However, once you start reading Hakamada’s story, the sad fact is that his story almost sounds commonplace. He was beaten during his interrogation and that was why he signed his “confession”. The latest DNA evidence undermines the evidence linking Hakamada to the murders. One of the judges who originally convicted him has stated publicly that he believed Hakamada was innocent, but that he was out voted by the other judges.

Ok, I hear you say, sure there are issues around Hakamada’s conviction, perhaps we shouldn’t put him to death, but what about those child rapists and murderers?

I’ll start firstly by saying that I am a mother and have two young boys. My fierce motherly instinct kicks in every time I hear those stories, much as I expect it does to anyone out there who isn’t a crazy psychotic child rapist. You can’t imagine anything worst than to hear that that has happened to your child.

Yet, how can we be sure?

The wrong person could be in the wrong place at the wrong time, and we would kill them just for being unfortunate. Let’s not forget that that person is probably also someone’s son or daughter, someone’s brother or sister, someone’s father or mother.

I hear you though, let’s say we actually catch them in the act, or something equally as damning.

What are you trying to achieve? Will it make you feel better if you kill that person? I’ll be honest here, probably. If some person had done something horrible like that to one of my children, it will sure as hell make me feel better if I kill them. However, what we are trying to do here is find a suitable solution for all criminals.

The death penalty just simply doesn’t work.

A child rapist has deep seeded psychological issues. The threat of being put to death is not going to stop that person raping children. The same with murderers. The murders that are committed under passion or some other strong emotion, those people don’t stop to think about anything, let alone what would happen if they get caught. The ones that are planned meticulously (i.e. cold blooded, pre-meditated murder), well they are planning them meticulously, they don’t expect to get caught. So the death penalty isn’t going to magically improve society. It will not stop these violent crimes from happening. It is the old clichéd ambulance at the bottom of the cliff scenario.

The death penalty cannot always get it right.

Everyone agrees that the justice system, despite our best intentions, is flawed. There is widespread systemic discrimination, corruption at all levels, inconsistencies just simply because we are human. Every day we hear of someone that has been released after years of being in prison because of new evidence… and yet we think it is ‘good enough’ to base someone’s death on? I’ve rambled enough now, i’ll end with a quote from Governor Pat Quinn… I think that it says exactly what I am trying to

“The evidence presented to me by former prosecutors and judges with decades of experience in the criminal justice system has convinced me that it is impossible to devise a system that is consistent, that is free of discrimination on the basis of race, geography or economic circumstance, and that always gets it right.”

– Governor Pat Quinn of Illinois, USA

More Information

5 thoughts on “It’s not a sentence, it’s a full stop

  1. Great post Vivian. Besides the death penalty being ineffective as a deterrent, and an irreversible punishment within an imperfect justice system, I despise the death penalty for another reason.

    I believe that murder – like torture – dehumanises both the victim and the perpetrator. And where the state carries out this punishment on behalf of its citizens, we are all implicated in this act. I don’t want to be responsible for someone’s death, even at arm’s length. And as a society, we debase ourselves and lose the moral high ground when we stoop to this level.

    Yes, I would change my tune if my kids were involved – which is really just an argument for why grieving relatives should not run a justice system!

    But I’m left wondering, for Hakamuda, maybe it is the sentence – 43 years of not knowing – rather than the full stop that makes the punishment seem so especially cruel.

  2. Yes Nic, I agree. oh-so-much to say! That was the crucial point that I had missed, by having the death penalty in the country that you live in, you are saying as a citizen of that country that you approve of state-sanctioned murder. A sobering thought

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s